I said "yes" because a condom was always required when I was still allowed to have PIV sex, except for the times when we were trying to conceive. She wasn't fond of having semen dripping out of her, and condoms also helped me last a few seconds longer.
I had to use snugger fit condoms and then, later, custom Perfect Fit condoms, because regular condoms would leave a lot unrolled and would often fall off during sex. When she told me not to bother ordering any more I knew she was serious about making me "pussy free for life."