As a newcomer to this kink I have studied English language material about it available online for the past 4 months or so. I've dabbled in it myself both solo and with my wife acting as keyholder. I'll summarize my observations and thoughts here.
A lot of what I have noted above from my observations are put forth as enticements or benefits to the life style/kink. But if your relationship doesn't suffer from any of these issues then they are meaningless to you. So if you have a normal working penis and a normal healthy sex life with your wife the "problems" Male Chastity can solve don't exist in your life.
As for the female side of things. I have seen it reported that most women are put off by the whole thing at first but also most women can be talked into trying it to make their husband/man happy. It can become burdensome to manage the male's orgasms and penis. Most men expect more tease and denial than most women are able to provide due to other constraints (work, life, children, etc.). This is probably the biggest source of issues with this kink: men being demanding, trying to control it all from a supposed position of submission, and pushing the woman to do more than she is comfortable with.
So why doesn't it work for me and my wife? Well we don't have any of those problems I pointed out that are often held out as something Male Chastity life styles can help with (except masturbation). Aside from that my wife is submissive and not comfortable in a femdom role. She'd rather I train myself for quickie sex than she deny me or lock me up. So the whole dynamic doesn't really work for us. She has neither the time nor the inclination to engage in femdom, tease and denial, or any of it. Her solution to my libido is quickie sex - just get me to orgasm with PIV sex (my favorite) and she can get on with her day. I'm more than willing to provide as much oral sex and orgasms to her as she wants - in fact I perform oral sex and bring her to orgasm more than she actually wants. So there's no apparent sexual benefit for either of us in this kink.
Physiologically I can benefit from orgasm denial due to the increased energy to use on other tasks/hormonal changes. I will continue to practice self denial, sometimes self caging for masturbation control, and try to get my wife to engage as a keyholder sometimes but I see it more as an extended foreplay practice for less than a week than as something that would extend longer than that. Other than that male chastity and the cages are a tool she has in her wife toolbox should she need to correct me or fix some behavioral issue. But it doesn't seem like a life style for us, just a sex game and occasional corrective tool my wife can use.
- Some men who engage in this have severe ED
- Some men who engage in this have unusually small penises
- Often it is cited as a way to cure "dead bedroom" syndrome (i.e. low sexuality in marriage)
- Often it is cited as a way to get wives more engaged sexually in a marriage
- Often it is cited as a way to get husbands to perform oral sex or more often
- Often it is cited as a way to get husbands to give their wives more orgasms or more focus on female sexual pleasure
- Some men who engage in this complain of little to no libido/sex drive in their wife
- Cross over into other kinks beyond male chastity and femdom is extremely common
- A large majority of women are uncomfortable with the whole thing, at first
- Some men/women use this to control/prevent male masturbation
A lot of what I have noted above from my observations are put forth as enticements or benefits to the life style/kink. But if your relationship doesn't suffer from any of these issues then they are meaningless to you. So if you have a normal working penis and a normal healthy sex life with your wife the "problems" Male Chastity can solve don't exist in your life.
As for the female side of things. I have seen it reported that most women are put off by the whole thing at first but also most women can be talked into trying it to make their husband/man happy. It can become burdensome to manage the male's orgasms and penis. Most men expect more tease and denial than most women are able to provide due to other constraints (work, life, children, etc.). This is probably the biggest source of issues with this kink: men being demanding, trying to control it all from a supposed position of submission, and pushing the woman to do more than she is comfortable with.
So why doesn't it work for me and my wife? Well we don't have any of those problems I pointed out that are often held out as something Male Chastity life styles can help with (except masturbation). Aside from that my wife is submissive and not comfortable in a femdom role. She'd rather I train myself for quickie sex than she deny me or lock me up. So the whole dynamic doesn't really work for us. She has neither the time nor the inclination to engage in femdom, tease and denial, or any of it. Her solution to my libido is quickie sex - just get me to orgasm with PIV sex (my favorite) and she can get on with her day. I'm more than willing to provide as much oral sex and orgasms to her as she wants - in fact I perform oral sex and bring her to orgasm more than she actually wants. So there's no apparent sexual benefit for either of us in this kink.
Physiologically I can benefit from orgasm denial due to the increased energy to use on other tasks/hormonal changes. I will continue to practice self denial, sometimes self caging for masturbation control, and try to get my wife to engage as a keyholder sometimes but I see it more as an extended foreplay practice for less than a week than as something that would extend longer than that. Other than that male chastity and the cages are a tool she has in her wife toolbox should she need to correct me or fix some behavioral issue. But it doesn't seem like a life style for us, just a sex game and occasional corrective tool my wife can use.