This is a great thread. I’ve been wondering, too, how important a cage is for the various aspects of the dynamic, which are very well summed up in the posts to this thread. Looking at some of the topics, here are some thoughts and questions to explore further. In my relationship, we don’t use a cage, but I am curious about what it brings to the table. We achieve increased intimacy, I have self control, we have a lovely dance of dominance and submission between us, we do lots of tease and denial and play time (for both of us), we have found paths to greater intimacy and connection, etc.
Follow my crazy logic and I’d love to get thoughts…
My hypothesis is that if presented in the right way, a cage could enhance the experience. And it could also be seen as a ‘weird’ thing that distracts from the potential connection. ie if it’s presented as a masturbation control method…could beg the question of “why are you doing that and not saving that energy for me already”? - which could totally derail the pursuit of greater intimacy. And if the environment exists in which to present a cage objectively, then that enhanced communication it is intended to provide will have already been achieved through the open and honest discussion. Which has the side benefit of making it easier to introduce and discuss openly. Chicken or the egg...cage first or trust and good communication first?
Summing up some of the topics from the thread:
Self discovery, probably tied to self control and change ones mindset around sex and male sexuality. I can see how a cage can certainly help with this, but having self control requires personal discipline and, well…self control already. Is the cage more symbolic and a powerful symbol? This is tied to masturbation control, where a cage highlights the attention paid to arousal and masturbation.
Improve intimacy - Is a cage needed for this or is it a change in mindset to focus more on her, letting her lead and allowing a feminine dynamic to dominate vs the masculine penis and goal-focused mindset?
Related to “intimate and honest conversation” - Does a cage facilitate open and honest conversation or can this occur regardless of the cage? Why is the cage a prerequisite?
Help with feeling submissive - submission is about wearing the cage for oneself, not their partner. Where submission is an inward focus of attention on the self (we want it for the powerful feeling the symbol invokes and the physical embracing feeling we get). I find it interesting to consider that submissive is an inward focus, whereas dominant is an outward focus of attention (courtesy of Kasia Urbaniak). Are we being submissive when caged to have our sexual intimacy needs met? And dominant when we are ‘serving’ our partner, which puts them in a submissive state to have their needs met in an inward focus (e.g. enjoying a back rub, having dishes washed, etc)? Are we being submissive when providing acts of service or are we letting our spouse enjoy submission to enjoy our service? And if we want to be truly subservient (submitting and serving) to someone, shouldn’t we be capable of doing that without a cage first?
Female leadership - by switching the scripts and changing the dynamic, we are creating an environment for the feminine to lead and ‘flow’, taking things in an interesting and unique direction, different than the goal focused dynamic men drive for and that we are used to. Can this happen without chastity? Does creating a non-stereotypical penis/masculine focused environment let the feminine flourish and women to have more experience though which they can gain confidence and become more expressive (aka ‘dominant’)? We haven’t needed a cage to see personal growth and confidence.
Tease and denial - I don’t think this has anything specifically to do with a chastity cage. But is a power shift and change in expectations between a couple. Does simply agreeing that she will decide what happens and doesn’t and when he gets to orgasm achieve the same thing? Is a cage needed for this dynamic to exist? Being endlessly horny and frustrated. Does NOT masturbating, not having an orgasm, and giving her control over these things achieve the same or similar result (though perhaps with less of the symbolic power)?
Kink and excitement - the chastity dynamic and cage (as with any kind of BDSM activity or equipment) provides something new to explore. Also goes with loving tight clothing and the kinesthetic aspect of these things. And helps provide additional stimulation and something to do (in what could be an otherwise ho hum sex life)…let’s face it, guys love gadgets. And we love our dicks. What could be more fun than gadgets on our dicks? It’s a match made in heaven.
Improved dynamic between a couple, excitement. Is the cage responsible for this, or is it the change in mindset, goals and who is leading the dynamic? Goes with novelty and rekindled excitement and improved intimacy.
Comparing my own journey to some that I read here, in some cases guys might achieve far better results not focusing on or introducing a cage. It seems like it can create a big hurdle and distraction vs taking a different approach focused on the specific desired outcomes and change in relationship dynamic that both partners can relate to and both benefit from.
Given all this, what are your experience with/without a cage and how does the dynamic change in either case and if all of this was established before a cage, how did the cage enhance your relationship?
Whew...hopefully that wasn't too confusing to understand.